“The problem with the world is that
the intelligent people are full of doubts, while the stupid ones are
full of confidence.”
The above quote, attributed to Charles
Bukowski, has been circulating recently on my Facebook feed. I can
feel the eyes rolling from here, and I recognize the irony, but the
point is it keeps popping up and making me think about the real truth
and also the unfortunate fallout of this statement. While I think this
statement applies to many aspects of the world, and to people in
general, it specifically applies to politics and governance. To put
it bluntly, anyone who wants to be a leader, specifically a
politician in our modern system, is probably not someone you want to
have making decisions for you.
To be fair, I am sure there are a
handful of honestly well-meaning, educated, thoughtful individuals
who think they could make real change and good decisions in a
position of leadership out there. I will also concede that some of
the current corrupt batch of national/world leaders may have started
out as the above mentioned breed, and simply strayed from the
straight and narrow somewhere along the way. However, I find it hard
to believe that most or even many individuals in public office are
not self-serving, corrupt, and frankly unfit to hold the positions to which they have been elected. The obvious follow-up question to this, of course, is how in the hell did they get elected in the first place?
Well, that answer is obviously complex, but I think it comes down to a few very simple factors. Money is the primary one, and it doesn't take a lot of insight into the system to come to this conclusion. Brand development and marketing is the second. And brand loyalty is the third, and I think possibly the most important in the modern era of politics.
To back up for a moment, I want to address the kind of person who actually wants to run for office and pursues such a path. First of all, the ego necessary to move in this direction is.... remarkable. Especially when we move onto a national level. Local politicians are liberally mixed between the corrupt and the genuine camps, I would wager. Once one moves past that level into positions of real power and financial clout, however, I think the pressure of making correct decisions and not succumbing to the influences (financial and otherwise) of interested parties probably weeds out the good eggs, by and large. The nature of the system promotes corruption in the form of lobbyists and campaign funds (I won't go into campaign funding and lobbyists in depth here, but this is obviously the biggest and most gaping hole in our existing system. Institutionalized corruption is the root of most of the evil I am speaking about here, but it will take me off on a tangent and away from my points here.), so anyone not playing by the rules of the game stands a good chance of being forced out by the non-elected hegemony. The only ones who make it very far in the political game, in most cases, are the ones who agree to become corrupt, bowing to the will of those who hold the purse strings, and perpetuating the system that ensures their position.
Aside from a willingness to get into bed with questionable bedfellows, the belief of the individual that he or she is actually the best person, or even a competent person, to be making decisions that affect so many other individuals is astounding. Again, when we move beyond the local level, the patriarchal arrogance in the assertion that an individual should be making decisions for large and diverse masses is somewhat shocking. The system as it was designed by our forefathers (again, with the eye rolling) did not account for the sheer numbers of individuals their system would eventually control, nor the vastly differing ways of life these people would live, both from themselves and each other. Further, it did not account for the "career politician" that has become the necessity and the norm in the modern age with political leaders. The system is clearly broken, impractical, and inappropriate to serve the purpose it was originally intended for, and while this is not the point I wish to address in this particular essay, it bears mentioning to reiterate the wariness the thinking American citizen should use when approaching an individual who wishes to control such a system.
To say that anyone who actually desires political office should automatically be disqualified as a potential leader by virtue of their desire and the elements of the individual's personality this desire implies is a bit of an exaggeration, but only a bit. I think that those who would best serve as leaders for our nation, and the world for that matter, are those who do not desire positions of power, and do not have the personal ambition to seek out such positions. This, at least in theory, insulates these individuals from the influences and corruption inherent in our current system, and ensures a more objective individual to act as champion of the people, as they are elected to be. Implementing this theory, however, is more of a challenge than simply declaring that it should work. I don't think I need to go into the difficulties of getting these individuals into office, or even in identifying them.
These ideal leaders are the ones about which the Bukowski quote at the beginning of this essay is speaking. Not the ignorant and stupid, but the intelligent individuals who are full of doubt and think they are unqualified to be the leader of others. This knowledge of their own ignorance and a reluctance to even wrestle with the complexities and the sheer enormity of the issues that a leader at the national level is asked to address imbues caution, respect, and long considered opinions on issues and decisions. To contrast this to an ignorant nonchalance or confidence an individual has in themselves to blithely make correct decisions when in a position of power makes the decision of which kind of leader I believe should hold positions of power quite clear. An unwavering, predetermined, dogmatic belief system is one that looks attractive on paper, or more accurately in front of an audience at a televised campaign rally, but in practice lacks a thoughtful approach to issues that affect actual people and not simply polling popularity numbers.
Unfortunately, I think that politics has become less about issues, or picking a leader(s) that will accurately reflect the will of the people, and more about a polarized red versus blue mentality more appropriate for rooting for college football teams than choosing who will make decisions about our future as a nation and as individuals. Political belief systems have been reduced to party loyalties, which are more often than not passed along from parents to children, or as a part of a social identity dictated by regionality or social status. It has become a system of "I root for the Red Team, because my daddy votes for the Red Team, and all my friends cheer for the Red Team, so of course they are my team too. What does the Red Team actually stand for? Red values, of course. And I believe in Red. So Red is best, and anything Blue is evil." Feel free to substitute Red for Blue and vice versa here, though in my personal opinion the Red Team has done a much better job of perpetuating this blind faith and loyalty in its core demographic over the last few decades than the Blue Team. It seems that Red Team may have finally shot themselves in the foot with their messages of hate and intolerance, and may be starting to lose its grip on some of their faithful, but there are still many that keep waving the flag despite, or perhaps because of, these stances.
If the previous paragraph has lead you to believe, theoretical reader, that I am in the camp of Team Blue, you are unfortunately mistaken. This dichotomy of Team Red and Team Blue sets us up too easily for Us vs Them, Good vs Evil, and every heroic tale of the underdog fighting against the powers that be in pursuit of the greater good that perhaps only the hero can see. This status quo set us up for failure from the beginning, as was warned by Washington in his Farewell Address. The two party system in its current utterance is simply a well-orchestrated show to allow the American citizenry to believe they are still in some control of the path our country is pursuing. The more we learn about the actual workings of the system, however, the more it becomes clear that the entirety is a farce. The system simply keeps the same important players in power, only allowing individuals to play if they have demonstrated a willingness and ability to play within the set of established rules. In reality, though stances on some social issues may differ, there is little difference between the two parties, other than a mascot and a team color.
To say that anyone who actually desires political office should automatically be disqualified as a potential leader by virtue of their desire and the elements of the individual's personality this desire implies is a bit of an exaggeration, but only a bit. I think that those who would best serve as leaders for our nation, and the world for that matter, are those who do not desire positions of power, and do not have the personal ambition to seek out such positions. This, at least in theory, insulates these individuals from the influences and corruption inherent in our current system, and ensures a more objective individual to act as champion of the people, as they are elected to be. Implementing this theory, however, is more of a challenge than simply declaring that it should work. I don't think I need to go into the difficulties of getting these individuals into office, or even in identifying them.
These ideal leaders are the ones about which the Bukowski quote at the beginning of this essay is speaking. Not the ignorant and stupid, but the intelligent individuals who are full of doubt and think they are unqualified to be the leader of others. This knowledge of their own ignorance and a reluctance to even wrestle with the complexities and the sheer enormity of the issues that a leader at the national level is asked to address imbues caution, respect, and long considered opinions on issues and decisions. To contrast this to an ignorant nonchalance or confidence an individual has in themselves to blithely make correct decisions when in a position of power makes the decision of which kind of leader I believe should hold positions of power quite clear. An unwavering, predetermined, dogmatic belief system is one that looks attractive on paper, or more accurately in front of an audience at a televised campaign rally, but in practice lacks a thoughtful approach to issues that affect actual people and not simply polling popularity numbers.
Unfortunately, I think that politics has become less about issues, or picking a leader(s) that will accurately reflect the will of the people, and more about a polarized red versus blue mentality more appropriate for rooting for college football teams than choosing who will make decisions about our future as a nation and as individuals. Political belief systems have been reduced to party loyalties, which are more often than not passed along from parents to children, or as a part of a social identity dictated by regionality or social status. It has become a system of "I root for the Red Team, because my daddy votes for the Red Team, and all my friends cheer for the Red Team, so of course they are my team too. What does the Red Team actually stand for? Red values, of course. And I believe in Red. So Red is best, and anything Blue is evil." Feel free to substitute Red for Blue and vice versa here, though in my personal opinion the Red Team has done a much better job of perpetuating this blind faith and loyalty in its core demographic over the last few decades than the Blue Team. It seems that Red Team may have finally shot themselves in the foot with their messages of hate and intolerance, and may be starting to lose its grip on some of their faithful, but there are still many that keep waving the flag despite, or perhaps because of, these stances.
If the previous paragraph has lead you to believe, theoretical reader, that I am in the camp of Team Blue, you are unfortunately mistaken. This dichotomy of Team Red and Team Blue sets us up too easily for Us vs Them, Good vs Evil, and every heroic tale of the underdog fighting against the powers that be in pursuit of the greater good that perhaps only the hero can see. This status quo set us up for failure from the beginning, as was warned by Washington in his Farewell Address. The two party system in its current utterance is simply a well-orchestrated show to allow the American citizenry to believe they are still in some control of the path our country is pursuing. The more we learn about the actual workings of the system, however, the more it becomes clear that the entirety is a farce. The system simply keeps the same important players in power, only allowing individuals to play if they have demonstrated a willingness and ability to play within the set of established rules. In reality, though stances on some social issues may differ, there is little difference between the two parties, other than a mascot and a team color.
No comments:
Post a Comment